?

Log in

Bwahaha! - Checkmated Rejects [entries|archive|friends|userinfo]
Checkmated Rejects

[ userinfo | livejournal userinfo ]
[ archive | journal archive ]

Links
[Links:| Checkmated Simply Undeniable The Quidditch Pitch Fiction Alley Sycophant Hex Fanfiction.net ]

Bwahaha! [Feb. 8th, 2009|11:00 pm]
Checkmated Rejects

checkmatedrejex

[mickawber_fics]
[Current Mood |amusedamused]

I thought I'd share this with you lot because you'd find it amusing.

Early last week, I was informed that my NC-17 fic Fantasy had been nominated for this year's rhr_awards. W00t! I'm very pleased indeed.

Not having even considered submitting to CM in a couple of years, I thought, Hey, here's an excuse! Submitted the fic. And today got back this reply:

    Dear antosha,
    We regret to inform you that we must reject your story, Fantasy, at this time.



    At present, this story...

    ~ is not something we are interested in hosting at Checkmated.
    ~ has canon errors or inconsistencies.
    ~ does not meet standard of quality.
    ----poor characterization.


I'm guessing that those canon errors included the idea that Ron and Hermione actually dated other people between Ch. 34 of DH and the time of the fic, some four or five years later (though they're happily married at the time of the story) and that the poor characterization involved the person with whom Hermione briefly hung out being female.

Damn! Where did I miss the pages in canon that said they got married the day after Voldemort's defeat, and that none of the HP characters—but certainly not Hermione—ever engaged in a homosexual affair? Did you see that anywhere? Was it in Beedle the Bard, maybe? XD

(The first criterion would have been fine with me. "Not our cup of tea. Didn't like it." No problem. It'd even be fine with me if—like SIYE with H/G—they simply banned all fics in which Ron and Hermione dated anyone but each other. But the other criteria? :snort: Yeahno.)

It still chaps my hide that CM mods can claim such telepathic powers of canon insight when it comes to Ron and Hermione's behavior, but are happy to accept fics pairing Harry or Ginny with anything with a pulse—even characters whom they show ever appearance in canon of disliking. But then, that's Earth Logic....
LinkReply

Comments:
[User Picture]From: drcjsnider
2009-02-09 01:39 pm (UTC)
I noticed the decline in ron/hermione fics there as well... I think it is hard to meet all their 'characterization' requirements... very little room left for anything innovative
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)